Skip to main content

A-Z Blogging Challenge: E is for...Elsie Marley

This is a rhyme that I hadn't heard until I started this challenge although some people I have spoken to have been surprised that I hadn't heard it so I'm learning stuff from this too.

'Elsie Marley's grown so fine.
She won't get up to feed the swine,
But lies in bed 'til eight or nine!
And surely does she take her time.'

This little rhyme seems innocent enough. Elsie is obviously a lady who has, for what ever reason, got ideas above her station. She has become so fine that she won't get out of bed before 8 or 9am and refuses to feed the pigs. When she does get up she certainly doesn't rush to do anything.

The rhyme has been changed with good reason. Her name was actually Eppie Marly. Here is the original.

Bonnie Prince Charlie
'Saw ye Eppie Marly, honey,
The woman that sells the barley, honey?
She's lost her pocket and a' her money,
Wi followin' Jacobite Charlie, honey.

Eppie Marly's turned sae fine,
She'll no gang oot tae herd the swine,
But lies in her bed 'til eight or nine,
And winnae come doon the stairs tae dine.'

Jacobite Charlie is Charles Edward Stuart (1720 - 1788) also known as Bonnie Prince Charlie, The Young Chevalier and The Young Pretender. For 40 years the Stuarts had been exiled in Italy and France; England was ruled by King George II but Bonnie Prince Charlie decided it was time to make a comeback and laid claim to the thrones of Scotland, England and Ireland.

In 1745 he arrived in Scotland and started to rally his troops. He was a popular figure and men women and children readily followed him. Eppie Marly was clearly one of them. As this is not a history lesson I'm not going into great detail here but the culmination of all this was the Battle of Culloden. The Scots were outnumbered by the English and the massacre began. The order 'No Quarter Given' was issued. This means that no-one should be allowed to live. Every wounded Highlander was killed. Virtually no-one survived. The killing continued with men, women and children being massacred at every opportunity by bayonet, hanging, musket...many others lay where they fell as entire villages were burned to the ground. Bonnie Prince Charlie survived and returned to Italy where he eventually died but the 1745 Rebellion and the Battle of Culloden will never be forgotten.

After that any reference to Bonnie Prince Charlie would be very dangerous and so the first part of the rhyme was discarded and the name changed to Elsie Marley.


Unknown said…
The history of rhymes fascinates me, thanks for sharing this.

Look forward to your challenge run…
--Damyanti, Co-host A to Z Challenge April 2012

Twitter: @AprilA2Z
Unknown said…
Fabulous post - I'd never heard of those rhymes but it's amazing how history affected them. The Battle of Culloden - not England's finest hour :-(
I've never heard this one either but I love it. And I love the language in the original version. I love reading your posts.
K.S. Lewis said…
Very, very interesting. Love learning the truth behind these rhymes, especially the ones I've never heard of before. Can't wait to see more.
Shannon said…
Very interesting and informative post..I myself have never heard that rhyme...will be following you now.

(new running blog about surviving cancer to becoming a runner)
Thanks for the background on this rhyme. I used to read it to my kids. I always knew nursery rhymes did not mean what we think they do. Great perspective.
Ella said…
This was fascinating! Thanks for sharing :D
Nice to meet you~
Denise said…
Damyanti - glad you're enjoying the rhymes.

Susan - thank you. The thought of what went on at Culloden makes me very sad.

Jaye - thank you. The Scots language actually flows really well.

K.S. - thanks. I'm learning stuff every day too from this.

Shannon- thanks. Just popping over to your blog now. Enjoy the rest of the challenge.

Yvonne - thank you. It's funny to think that perfectly innocent little rhymes like this can actually mean so much.

Ella - thanks for dropping by. Enjoy the challenge.
Jenni Steel said…
I have always been aware of the fight at Culloden with the English but I never really knew the story behind it.

Thanks for enlightening me.

Popular posts from this blog

Stop! It's Going Too Fast and I Want to Get Off!

Carousel Okay - I don't actually mean that I want things to stop so that I can get off because I'm having too much fun but, over the last few months, my life has become a daily whirlwind of new businesses, taking on new projects, building websites and building a brand and it's not showing any sign of slowing down. I have loved every minute of it so far but it has meant that so many other things in my life have had to be put on the back burner whilst all this has been going on, including Cupcakes and Cadenzas. It will all have been worth it in the long run but I just want to say thanks to everyone who has stuck around and not abandoned this blog and to say that I haven't forgotten about it or you. Why I love Cupcakes and Cadenzas so much and refuse to give up on it it is that it was the very first blog that I set up and is therefore my 'baby' as far as blogs go. I have several other blogs set up for various business ventures but Cupcakes and Cadenzas is

Shake it Off Like a Donkey

Some time ago I heard this little story and it really had an impact on me so I thought I would share it with you.  "There was once a farmer who owned a prize donkey. One day the donkey fell into a very deep well next to the farmer's house and began to panic at the bottom of the well when he realised there was no way out. Because the well was so deep, the farmer could see no way to help the poor donkey and so he decided that the only course of action to take was to bury it in the well and, in that way, end its suffering and stop its crying. With a heavy heart and tears in his eyes the farmer began to shovel dirt into the well to bury the little donkey. However, the donkey had no intention of being buried and so, every time the farmer threw a shovelful of dirt into the well, the donkey shook it off his back then stepped up on to it. The farmer kept shovelling and the donkey kept shaking the dirt off. Eventually the donkey had shaken off and stepped on so much dirt th